Page 1 of 1

General scaling back of self-checkouts

Posted: August 2nd, 2024, 11:18 am
by Super S
It appears that many large retailers are scaling back self-checkouts to some extent.

I have some local observations:

Walmart: Most of the time two banks of self-checkouts are closed with only a few immediately next to the regular registers are available. Nearly all of the few remaining traditional registers are open, but lines are long again and there is no "express lane" of any type clearly marked.

Fred Meyer: Two banks of self-checkouts on the grocery side are usually closed, with one bank open, which, in addition to 4 standard self-checkouts, has two lanes with belts that will randomly reverse and claim you didn't scan something, and are awkward to use. Usually only one or two of the 5 or 6 regular registers open with very long lines. Interestingly, the GM side has been self-checkout only for a few years (basically since the last remodel) and lines are MUCH shorter on that end of the store. There are 2 or 3 regular registers on the GM side but I have only seen them in use once since the remodel. This location used to have a reasonably staffed front end.

Safeway: No comment since I usually do not shop there. Last time I went through self-checkout at a time the store was not busy.

Target: All self-checkouts open, two marked "card only" with about 2 or 3 regular registers open. Lines usually are not long compared to Walmart & Fred Meyer.

WinCo: All self-checkouts open, with about 2 or 3 regular registers open most of the time. Half of self-checkouts are debit card only. Regular checkout lines get very long at times. (Some WinCo locations are completely removing self-checkouts in the Portland area)

Lowe's: They bank heavily on self-checkout and usually have one regular register open, sometimes two. Lumber end at least has a staffed register which was not always the case.

Home Depot: Basically the same as Lowe's.

Costco: I have seen them adding self-checkout but people are reluctant to use them for large orders, and I still see many using the regular registers. Sometimes with nobody at the open self-checkouts.

Basically the chains that invested heavily in self-checkouts seem to be backtracking with the exception of the home improvement chains.

Re: General scaling back of self-checkouts

Posted: August 2nd, 2024, 12:13 pm
by veteran+
Super S wrote: August 2nd, 2024, 11:18 am It appears that many large retailers are scaling back self-checkouts to some extent.

I have some local observations:

Walmart: Most of the time two banks of self-checkouts are closed with only a few immediately next to the regular registers are available. Nearly all of the few remaining traditional registers are open, but lines are long again and there is no "express lane" of any type clearly marked.

Fred Meyer: Two banks of self-checkouts on the grocery side are usually closed, with one bank open, which, in addition to 4 standard self-checkouts, has two lanes with belts that will randomly reverse and claim you didn't scan something, and are awkward to use. Usually only one or two of the 5 or 6 regular registers open with very long lines. Interestingly, the GM side has been self-checkout only for a few years (basically since the last remodel) and lines are MUCH shorter on that end of the store. There are 2 or 3 regular registers on the GM side but I have only seen them in use once since the remodel. This location used to have a reasonably staffed front end.

Safeway: No comment since I usually do not shop there. Last time I went through self-checkout at a time the store was not busy.

Target: All self-checkouts open, two marked "card only" with about 2 or 3 regular registers open. Lines usually are not long compared to Walmart & Fred Meyer.

WinCo: All self-checkouts open, with about 2 or 3 regular registers open most of the time. Half of self-checkouts are debit card only. Regular checkout lines get very long at times. (Some WinCo locations are completely removing self-checkouts in the Portland area)

Lowe's: They bank heavily on self-checkout and usually have one regular register open, sometimes two. Lumber end at least has a staffed register which was not always the case.

Home Depot: Basically the same as Lowe's.

Costco: I have seen them adding self-checkout but people are reluctant to use them for large orders, and I still see many using the regular registers. Sometimes with nobody at the open self-checkouts.

Basically the chains that invested heavily in self-checkouts seem to be backtracking with the exception of the home improvement chains.
Excellent..................perhaps they are finally waking up from the nightmare they created.

Now, about those lines :oops:

Re: General scaling back of self-checkouts

Posted: August 2nd, 2024, 10:18 pm
by Alpha8472
I have noticed no self checkout at Home Depot in the most dangerous areas of the San Francisco Bay Area. This is in the Oakland area. There is no Home Depot in the entire city of San Francisco.

Out in the suburbs that are very distant and safe, it is mostly cashier operated registers with perhaps one self checkout. An employee told me to use the unit as a self checkout, but it looked like the register the cashier was using.

San Francisco Bay Area Walmart Neighborhood Markets in good areas are totally self checkout with perhaps one attendant to open up a register for alcohol. Regular Walmart stores have lots of cashiers and only a small number of Self Checkouts. Many of those have employees are ringing you up at self checkout. Only paying is self serve.

Re: General scaling back of self-checkouts

Posted: August 2nd, 2024, 11:53 pm
by storewanderer
Other than inept retailers like Five Below who force the cashier to scan your items for you on a self checkout then leave for you to do payment, or these Dollar General units that disabled self checkout, not seeing much change. Five Below the stores are deserted and I have yet to wait for checkout. Dollar General is another story with one cashier and 5-15 minute wait times to checkout, this is a disaster there, and I've quit shopping their stores entirely unless I drive by and see 2 cars out front.

The Wal Marts are mostly back to normal except the one Reno Kietzke Store that removed the non food side self checkouts and barely opens the corral of self checkouts by grocery (they keep 10 belted self checkouts in line with the regular checkstands open at all times however). The project to remove all self checkouts from that store was suspended for now and they just did an inventory again...

It is pretty simple for me: I'm not satisfied if I wait in a line for more than about 90 seconds for checkout. I don't really care if it is self checkout or cashier, I just don't want a wait greater than 90 seconds. But given the choice I'll pick self checkout.

Re: General scaling back of self-checkouts

Posted: August 21st, 2024, 1:02 am
by storewanderer
Hy-Vee is all over the place when it comes to self checkouts.

Most stores- nothing is going on, they are open... period.

One store had a sign- "self checkouts are now limited to 12 items."
Another store had an identical sign to the above in format/print but "self checkouts are now limited to 20 items."
Both of those stores seemed to be in perfectly fine neighborhoods.

Another store was most interesting. The store has short hours due to supposed "shoplifting issues in the evening" yet the store is physically 100% self checkout at the front end. There was a security guard watching self checkout who was armed with a visible gun. Actually did not see a normal Hy Vee employee watching self checkout. I was the only customer using it in the middle of the day. Store was DEAD. The only staffed checkout was at a secondary door next to their Starbucks and not a normal register but just a counter (no belt, etc.). Zero lock up merchandise in this store. I think it has volume issues, major volume issues.

Another store was also interesting. Supposedly in a "bad part of town" according to locals, but those people have no clue what a "bad part of town" is if they thought this was a "bad part of town..." they should come out west or venture over to St. Louis or Chicago's "bad parts of town..." This store had "entry gates" at the door like some Wal Marts have, locked restrooms after a certain time, and NO self checkout (they were removed).

A third store (rural) was 100% self checkout but had positioned a couple of them to be cashier lanes (first time I've seen this done since Fresh & Easy). I thought this was strange they made it 100% self checkout.